Fix The Ace - Saving NBC's New Poker Show

I watched the new poker gameshow “Face the Ace” on Saturday and was a bit disappointed. Sure, I liked it, but I would like any new poker show, really. But watching this new show I realized there were some fundamental problems with it. The ratings confirmed it, as the show finished last in its time slot. From a poker player’s perspective, the show needs some fundamental changes if it’s going to make it.

The Contestants

They’re not necessarily charismatic, interesting, or even sympathetic. Jonathan Nygaard, the first contestant was a mumbling, boring, non-compelling guy. I am sure he’s a nice dude, but nice dudes don’t necessarily make for great television. As long as they choose contestants through online qualifiers, this is what you will get. It will be hit and miss.

So have contestant searches and choose more on personality than on winning a ridiculous online qualifier. Try to get some guys (or gals) in there that we can root for, or contestants we’re going to enjoy rooting against. The bottom line is, if we don’t care about the people playing, the public won’t tune in.

The Host is Horrible

Get rid of Steve Schirripa. He is like a fish out of water as the host. You need a host who can make this interesting, he fails.

The “Aces” Don’t Care

Why should they? Yes, $10,000 to charity is very nice, but does Phil Ivey care about winning the match? No.

This is one problem the show might not be able to solve. How do you make this freeroll match mean something for the pro that is playing for nothing? Side bets between the pros might make it a little more dramatic. The lack of interest the pros have might have shown itself when the pros were 0-3 against the qualifiers in the opening show.

Who are the “Aces”

I know who they are. You know who they are. I would imagine, however, that the real target audience for this show is the casual fan. When the Ace is picked, give us a nice video montage-style biography of the guy to really pump him up so there is some drama. Make this about the personalities because it’s certainly not about the great poker.

Why go for it?

I think the contestant on show one who goes for the million might be the last one ever. I mean, $200K to the average guy is a buttload of cash. So, why will anyone else go for it? If they lost it all, then there is no incentive since $200K will make them very happy.

What about guaranteed money after they win a match or two? After they win the $200K match, maybe lock in $50K as guaranteed winning.

How about adding some other elements to the show? Offer them insurance to buy out if they get it all in? Something, anything, to make this show interesting.

Conclusion

It could be worse. They could offer contestants the ability to get “coaching” in the middle of a hand or something equally as bad, but they didn’t. Now, make it interesting. Most are not tuning in for great poker, so focus on the people and make us care. Unfortunately the show has potential, but does not deliver. Without some quick fixes, I just don’t think it can make it.

Problems of Regulating Poker

National Poker Week just concluded, and by all accounts it was a great success. So what are we hoping to come out of this lobbying effort? Everyone wants licensed, regulated, legal online poker. And we might just get it. But we shouldn’t be celebrating yet. Any bill, at least as currently proposed, faces a world of hurdles. Here are just two:

Issue 1: Poker is different from other forms of online gambling.

We all know poker is a game of skill. It takes a lot of skill to play as badly as I do. But despite what we know as poker players, most of the general public just see poker as “gambling.” They think poker and craps are just about the same. You bet. Sometimes you get lucky, sometimes you don’t. Part of National Poker Week was focused on educating legislators on the skill involved in poker, as opposed to other casino games.

The current legislation proposed by Barney Frank, however, does not distinguish between poker and other casino games. It aims to legalize all internet gambling and to then tax and regulate it as well. The upside is that it will make online gaming a lot safer for the public. The downside? The bill may be D.O.A. because it includes other forms of gambling.

While we as poker players have a great response to the “this is just gambling and gambling is evil” argument, we don’t have as strong an argument as it relates to other games of pure chance. Because Frank has included all online gaming, this bill might face an uphill battle. Understandably, Frank’s bill focuses on personal liberty, and Frank is not so much a champion of poker’s cause as he is the cause of personal choice. While it’s laudable, in practice it might just hinder our chances of getting regulated online poker.

Issue 2: States might opt out.

Surely any finalized bill will allow states to opt out of legal regulated online gaming. It’s pretty much a constitutional requirement to have such an opt out. But in this case, it could mean that the poker legislation will have no teeth, as many states will want out.

States like New Jersey might see Internet gaming as a threat to their brick and mortar operations. These gambling states could very well choose not to let residents play online if they think it will hurt the huge casino industry.

In addition, more conservative states could opt out as well. It would not be surprising to see Bible Belt states choosing not to let residence play online. In the end, it could mean that any bill legalizing and regulating online poker leaves a majority of the citizens in the United States out in the cold.

Remembering the Klondike

Okay, so my first post on a “poker blog” isn’t poker related… deal with it. I guess it’s semi poker-related considering the trip in question was made as sort of a poker pilgrimage with a friend I met playing poker, and my wife, whom I also met playing poker. See a trend?

We were going to Vegas to hang out, play some cards, and otherwise just be degenerates. As we planned our trip we found out something sad; the Klondike Casino was closing, and our first night there would be the Klondike’s last.

What the hell is the Klondike? Well, if you’ve ever seen Vegas Vacation, you know the Klondike. You know the locals casino where they play “Pick a Hand”? That was the Klondike. Okay, they didn’t really play “Pick a Hand” at the ‘Dike, but it wasn’t much better. It was a lawless land of quarter roulette and penny slots. And that was before its impending doom. It was a place where one of their blackjack promotions almost bankrupted the joint. http://tinyurl.com/kw9zl5

So, the group of four of us, Me, my friend Chris, my brother Kevin, and my wife, Amanda, headed out to Vegas with a genius plan. For its last night, we would stay at the ‘Dike. The casino was located on the “strip” just before Mandalay Bay, across the Strip. It was right near the iconic Welcome to Las Vegas sign. The casino was about the size of my living room. It smelled of stale cigarettes and octogenarians. It was filled with slots that were about 12 years past their prime, and patrons that were about 40 years past theirs. It was a depressing place, but in the past, it had been a fun place for cheap gambling and local-mocking.

What we hadn’t taken into account, however, was that the last night of the Klondike was about 2 weeks after they closed the casino itself. You see, apparently the Nevada Gaming Commission wants things wrapped up in an orderly fashion when a casino closes, so the ‘Dike was offering no more gambling… well… no more sanctioned gambling.

The casino itself was filled with a depressing mix of locals without the ability to gamble, having one last beer at their favorite hang out. We decided to proceed to the hotel check in. The hotel itself was more of a multi level motel. You had to go outside to get to your room. The fact that the room was only $35 should have been a tip off. We spoke with the nice lady and got the keys to our rooms. It was still daylight when we walked outside, past the empty pool, to the row of motel rooms. My wife and I found our room, and Chris and Kevin found theirs.

The room was quaint. That is to say, it was nasty. The bed was bare, with the sheets and blankets piled on a chair in the corner. Oh, on top of that pile was a trash bag with someone’s wet bating suit. I thought it was a nice bonus. Amanda did not. The bathroom had no toilet paper, and the prospect of getting any was pretty bleak. The stains on the carpet were matched by the stains on the bedspread. Thank God we didn’t have a black light.

We walked down to Chris’s room, and he was sitting on his bed, staring into the drawer on the bedside table. I’ve never known Chris to be a particularly religious man, so I didn’t suspect he was perusing the Bible. He looked up at us. “Have you ever seen a crack pipe?” He asked? My wife answered (a little too quickly), “Yes, why?” “I think there’s one in my drawer,” he replied. There, sitting beside his bed in this scary little room was an obviously used crack pipe. Seems like the Klondike had some dirty little secrets.

It was time to regroup. We had rooms reserved at the palatial Sahara for the next few nights, and maybe they had a room opened tonight if we decided the Klondike wasn’t our cup of tea.

After discussing it we all decided it was time to at least head to the casino and get a drink. We needed time to calm down.

We walked toward the casino and noticed that the sidewalk was moving. Well, to be fair, the sidewalk was stationary, but the roaches that covered it were scurrying about. I have never seen this many cockroaches in one place. We walked faster. Then we walked past “the room.” There is a lot of controversy about what we saw next. The door to the motel room was slightly ajar, but inside was a contraption, on that we can all agree. But what I saw as some bizarre medieval medical device, the rest of my party believed was a sex swing. Whatever it was, it was horrifying. We were afraid that whatever troll it was that used this scary sex/medical device would start chasing us, so we raced to the safety of the casino.

The scene at the casino was reminiscent of Lord of the Flies. All justice and lawfulness had been replaced by mob rule. The huge roulette wheel in the middle of the room was being used, despite official gambling being discontinued at the ‘Dike two weeks prior. But now, small white chits of paper had become currency. There was a man eating a full chicken dinner in the middle of one of the roulette wheels. Security guards stood in the corner with an uneasy look upon their faces. The mob was frenzied. And we were scared.

The four of us made eye contact, and without another word, fled the gaming floor. We returned to our rooms, tiptoeing around the roaches, and grabbed our bags. We virtually ran to the front of the casino to hail a cab. Not a lot of cabs stop at the ‘Dike. We called a company that told us it would take an hour. As the drunks spilled out of the Klondike, fresh off of their illicit roulette wins, we became more uneasy. Finally we stepped up and basically threw ourselves in front of a cab to make him stop. Once inside, I don’t think any of us have ever been happier to be headed toward a second rate hotel. The Klondike may have history, but we didn’t particularly want to become part of its last chapter.